For a complete training guide on facilitation skills, see our guide to facilitating small groups.

For a complete step-by-step process, see our pastor search committee guide for small churches.

By Brent Lacy

Every church has conflict. The question is not whether conflict will come, but whether the church has the culture and the systems to handle it well when it does.

Most churches do not. They handle conflict reactively, waiting until it has escalated into a crisis before addressing it. By then, the damage is significant and the options are limited.

The most effective conflict management is conflict prevention. Here is how to build a church culture that handles disagreement well before it becomes destructive.

Why Churches Handle Conflict Poorly

Most churches handle conflict poorly for the same reasons.

• Conflict is avoided until it explodes. Small concerns are not addressed because addressing them feels uncomfortable. They accumulate until they become a crisis.
• There is no clear process. When conflict arises, nobody knows what to do. The Matthew 18 process exists in the Bible but not in the church’s culture or governance documents.
• Gossip is tolerated. Triangulation, talking to everyone except the person you have a problem with, is the default conflict response in most small churches. It is also the most destructive one.
• Leadership avoids hard conversations. Pastors and board members who are conflict-averse allow problems to fester rather than addressing them directly.

Building a Conflict-Healthy Culture

Model direct communication from the pulpit.

Preach about conflict, forgiveness, and reconciliation regularly. Not just when there is a crisis. A congregation that hears biblical teaching on conflict resolution will handle conflict more biblically.

Model it yourself. When you have a disagreement with a board member or a staff volunteer, handle it directly and transparently. The congregation learns how to handle conflict by watching how their leaders handle it.

Establish a clear conflict resolution process.

Write the Matthew 18 process into your church culture. Make it explicit: “In this church, when we have a problem with someone, we go to them directly first.” Put it in your membership class. Reference it from the pulpit. Make it the expected norm, not the exception.

Address gossip directly.

Gossip is one of the most destructive forces in a small church. It spreads quickly, it is almost impossible to correct once it has spread, and it poisons relationships and trust.

Address it directly when you encounter it. “I appreciate you sharing that with me. Have you talked to them directly? That is the right first step.” Do not participate in triangulation, even when it is tempting.

Early Intervention

The most important conflict prevention skill is early intervention, addressing concerns before they escalate.

When you notice tension between two people, address it early. A five-minute conversation when the concern is small is far easier than a two-hour mediation session when it has become a crisis.

When you hear a complaint about someone, ask: “Have you talked to them directly?” If not, encourage them to do so. If they have and it did not resolve, offer to help facilitate a conversation.

Clear Governance Prevents Conflict

Many church conflicts are not really about relationships. They are about unclear authority. Who has the right to make what decisions? When the answer is unclear, conflict fills the vacuum.

Clear bylaws, clear role descriptions for deacons and elders, and clear decision-making processes prevent a significant percentage of church conflicts before they start. See the church bylaws guide for a complete framework.

When Prevention Fails

Even the healthiest church cultures will have conflict that escalates beyond what prevention can address. When that happens, see the church conflict resolution guide for a practical framework for addressing conflict that has already escalated.

MinistryPlace has a full library of free resources for small and rural churches. No email required, no subscription, no catch.