For practical help writing a newsletter your congregation will actually read, see our church newsletter guide for small churches.

If your church is planning to honor your pastor, our pastor’s anniversary planning guide has practical ideas for doing it well.

By Brent Lacy

80% of small church ministry is carried out by volunteers. Finding them, training them, and keeping them is one of the most important leadership challenges in small church ministry.

Most small churches approach volunteer recruitment the same way. They make a general announcement from the pulpit. Nobody responds. They make it again. Still nothing. The pastor ends up doing it themselves — again.

The problem is not your people. The problem is the method. Here is a practical guide to volunteer management that actually works.

The One-Person Ask

The most effective volunteer recruitment in a small church is simple: ask one person at a time, for a specific role, with a clear time commitment.

Not: “We need help with children’s ministry.”

But: “I’d like to ask you to teach the 3rd through 5th grade Sunday school class on the first Sunday of each month. It’s about 45 minutes, and I’ll provide the lesson plan. Would you be willing to try it for three months?”

That ask works because it is specific, bounded, supported, and personal. You chose them. That matters.

Match People to Roles by Gifts

Desperation recruiting — asking whoever will say yes — fills slots but creates problems. A volunteer in the wrong role burns out faster and is harder to redirect.

Before you recruit, ask yourself: who in this congregation has the gifts, personality, and availability for this role? When you recruit based on fit, volunteers are more likely to stay and more likely to thrive.

The First 30 Days

Most small churches recruit volunteers and then leave them to figure it out. That is a retention problem waiting to happen. A simple 30-day onboarding process changes that:

• Week 1. Provide a written role description — what they do, when, and who to contact with questions.
• Week 2. Have them shadow an experienced volunteer or observe their first session with you present.
• Week 3. Check in personally. “How is it going? What do you need?”
• Week 4. Thank them by name in a service or newsletter.

Keeping the Volunteers You Have

Recruiting new volunteers is harder than keeping the ones you have. Retention comes down to three things: clear expectations, regular appreciation, and burnout prevention through rotation.

Build rotation into your volunteer system. No one should serve every single week in a demanding role. Even a once-a-month rotation gives people breathing room and prevents the exhaustion that leads to resignation.

Free Volunteer Management Resources

MinistryPlace has a full library of free resources for small and rural churches. No email required, no subscription, no catch.