Pastors can respond to Gen Z adults who use AI companions by asking what the tool does for them, discussing its limits, and offering real conversation and community. Start with the person’s experience. App use alone does not establish loneliness, a crisis of faith, or a lack of friendships.
An AI companion is designed to sustain a conversational or simulated relationship. That differs from using a general chatbot to draft an email or a voice assistant to set a reminder. Ask which product and features the person means.
What the research actually measures
Barna’s May 2026 report found that 39% of Gen Z respondents agreed that AI’s spiritual advice was as trustworthy as a pastor’s. Its U.S. adult survey was conducted in November 2025. This measures reported trust; it does not tell us how many respondents used companion apps or replaced a pastor with one.
The Cigna Group’s Loneliness in America 2025 report, using 2024 data, classified 67% of the Gen Z adults in its study as lonely. The report defines that cohort as people born from 1997 through 2006. Its findings are context for listening, not a diagnosis of an individual or evidence that AI caused loneliness.
Both findings concern adults. Use appropriate youth guidance when working with minors; do not apply adult survey percentages to every teenager in your church.
Ask questions that make room for an honest answer
- “What do you enjoy or find useful about the app?”
- “Do you mainly use it for conversation, role-play, reflection, or something else?”
- “When it gives advice, how do you decide whether to trust it?”
- “Has anything it said made you uncomfortable or confused?”
- “Is there anything you would like to talk through with another person?”
Listen before preparing a response. Do not require someone to hand over their phone, display private conversations, or explain personal experiences to a group. If they show a message voluntarily, discuss only what is needed and avoid copying it into another AI tool.
Discuss spiritual authority with a concrete example
If a person brings an AI-generated answer about God, forgiveness, or a moral decision, ask what persuaded them. Was it the Scripture reference, the reasoning, or the reassuring tone? Then open the relevant passage together.
Check whether the words are quoted accurately and whether the interpretation fits the surrounding text. Explain where your own answer comes from and be willing to say when you need further study. A pastor should earn trust through truthfulness, care, and accountability rather than demand it because an app is involved.
Christian teaching rests on God’s revelation in Scripture and the saving work of Jesus Christ. A generated response can be examined as an argument, but its confident wording is not a new revelation or a substitute for prayer, study, and accountable Christian community.
Talk about boundaries without guessing at harm
Ask whether the person is comfortable with the time, spending, and personal information involved. Review the product’s current settings and terms if help is wanted. A change in daily responsibilities or relationships is worth discussing on its own terms; it is not a reason to make a diagnosis from app use.
For private pastoral matters, use the church’s approved care process. Do not ask a chatbot to judge someone’s faith, decide whether a relationship is healthy, or handle a disclosure on your behalf. The AI Ethics in Ministry hub can help leaders agree on privacy, review, and responsibility.
Offer a next step you can actually keep
Ask whether another conversation, a shared meal, a Bible study, or an introduction would help. Make the invitation specific and leave room to decline. A small group with a clear welcome and reliable follow-up is more useful than a vague promise that the church is always available.
If someone wants to continue a conversation, agree on when and how. Keep private notes in approved records. For parents and youth leaders working with teenagers, see the separate guide to AI companions and teenagers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the 39% figure mean Gen Z uses AI instead of pastors?
No. Barna asked about trust in spiritual advice. That finding does not establish companion-app usage or the replacement of pastoral care.
Should I make AI companions a group discussion topic?
You can invite a general discussion about trust, privacy, and Scripture. Do not ask participants to identify who uses an app or disclose private conversations. Keep personal pastoral follow-up separate.
What should church volunteers agree on before using AI?
Agree on approved tasks, information that must stay out of prompts, who reviews content, and when AI assistance should be disclosed. Use your church’s established approval process.
Turn AI boundaries into shared practice
The paid Church AI Policy Kit provides six implementation documents, including a volunteer acknowledgment, communication template, rollout plan, decision guide, and review checklist. It helps leaders put an approved policy into practice.
Explore the Church AI Policy Kit
Start at no cost with the free Church AI Governance and Policy Kit.
Sources
- Barna: AI Is Becoming a Spiritual Authority, Even Among Practicing Christians, May 19, 2026. Read the survey dates and methods.
- The Cigna Group: Loneliness in America 2025. Uses 2024 data; includes cohort definitions and methodology.