By Brent Lacy

The pastor search process is designed to help churches and candidates find the right fit. But it can also obscure problems , on both sides. Committees sometimes present their church in the best possible light. Candidates sometimes present themselves in the best possible light. And both parties sometimes miss warning signs that would have saved everyone significant pain.

This guide is for candidates. Here are the red flags to watch for , and what to do when you see them.

Red Flags About the Previous Pastor

They cannot explain why the previous pastor left

Every pastoral departure has a story. If the committee is vague, evasive, or gives inconsistent answers about why the previous pastor left, that is a significant warning sign. The most common reasons for evasiveness: the departure was conflicted, the church bears significant responsibility for it, or there are ongoing legal or relational complications.

Ask directly: “Can you walk me through the circumstances of the previous pastor’s departure?” If the answer is “it was complicated” or “we’d rather not get into it,” press gently. You deserve to know.

They speak negatively about the previous pastor

A committee that speaks critically, dismissively, or bitterly about the previous pastor is telling you something important about how they will eventually speak about you. Healthy churches honor their previous pastors even when the departure was difficult.

The previous pastor left quickly

If the previous pastor served less than two years, ask why. Short tenures are sometimes unavoidable , health issues, family situations, clear calls elsewhere. But they can also signal a church that is difficult to lead, has unrealistic expectations, or has a pattern of conflict with pastoral leadership.

Red Flags About the Church’s Health

Declining attendance and giving without acknowledgment

Ask for attendance and giving trends over the past five years. If the numbers are declining and the committee does not acknowledge it or explain it, that is a concern. A church that cannot be honest about its challenges with a pastoral candidate will not be honest with its pastor.

Multiple short pastoral tenures

If the church has had three pastors in ten years, ask why. One short tenure can be explained. A pattern of short tenures suggests something systemic , unrealistic expectations, a controlling board, chronic conflict, or a culture that is difficult for pastoral leadership.

Significant factions or unresolved conflict

Ask directly: “Are there any significant conflicts or unresolved tensions in the congregation that I should know about?” A committee that says “no” when there clearly are , and you will often be able to tell , is not being honest with you. A committee that acknowledges conflict and explains how they are addressing it is being honest and healthy.

Red Flags About Expectations

Unrealistic availability expectations

If the committee expects the pastor to be available 24/7, to attend every church event, to make hospital visits within hours of admission, and to be the primary leader of every ministry , and the church is paying a bi-vocational salary , that is a mismatch that will create burnout and resentment.

Ask specifically: “What does the congregation expect from the pastor in terms of weekly hours and availability?” If the answer is vague or unrealistic, that is important information.

Compensation that has not kept pace

If the compensation package has not been reviewed or increased in several years, that tells you something about how the church values pastoral ministry. Ask when the compensation was last reviewed and how it is evaluated. A church that has not given a cost-of-living adjustment in five years is a church that may not be thinking carefully about pastoral care.

Governance that is unclear or controlling

Ask how decisions are made. Who has authority over what? How does the board or deacon team relate to the pastor? If the answer is unclear, or if it becomes clear that a small group of people controls the church regardless of formal governance structures, that is a significant concern.

Red Flags in the Process Itself

The committee is evasive or inconsistent

If committee members give different answers to the same question, or if they are evasive when you ask direct questions, that is a warning sign. A healthy search committee is honest about the church’s challenges because they know that a pastor who accepts a call without knowing the challenges will be blindsided by them.

They are in a hurry

A committee that is rushing the process , pressuring you to decide quickly, skipping steps, or discouraging you from asking questions , is a committee that may be more interested in filling the position than finding the right fit. The right church will give you time to discern.

They cannot articulate what success looks like

Ask: “What would make this a successful pastorate? What would make it a failed one?” If the committee cannot answer these questions clearly, they have not done the work of defining what they are looking for. That ambiguity will create problems.

What to Do When You See Red Flags

Name them directly

If you see a red flag, name it. “I noticed that you mentioned the previous pastor left under difficult circumstances. Can you tell me more about that?” A healthy committee will appreciate the directness. An unhealthy committee will become defensive , which is itself important information.

Consult your references and mentors

Before accepting a call to a church with significant red flags, talk to people who know you and know ministry. Share what you have observed. Ask for honest feedback. A mentor who has seen churches in conflict can help you assess whether what you are seeing is manageable or disqualifying.

Be willing to walk away

Walking away from the wrong call is not failure. It is wisdom. A pastor who accepts a call to a dysfunctional church out of desperation, financial pressure, or the desire to be wanted will almost always regret it. The right call is worth waiting for.

MinistryPlace has a full library of free resources for small and rural churches. No subscription required.