How to Conduct a Church Health Audit
Start with a free nine-question quick check. Use evidence and honest conversation.
A church health audit gives leaders a structured way to discuss strengths, concerns, and evidence. Start with the free two-page, nine-question quick check. For a fuller team process, the separate 15-page Church Health Audit Tool ($14.99) has 45 scored statements, a scorecard, action plans, and a 12-month tracker.
Most small church leaders have a general sense of where their church is struggling. But “general sense” is not the same as a clear picture. A structured health audit forces honest conversation about specific areas, surfaces blind spots, and creates a shared language for leadership discussions about church health.
Scoring a worksheet will not by itself improve a church. Its value is in the conversation that follows: listening to different perspectives, checking impressions against evidence, and taking a manageable next step.
The 9 Dimensions of Church Health
The full MinistryPlace audit uses the nine discussion areas below. These broad topics resemble those described in the Siburt Institute’s published Church Health Assessment overview. MinistryPlace’s worksheet is independently developed; it is not the institute’s validated instrument or an endorsed adaptation.
- Vision, Mission, and Goals , Does the church have a clear sense of where it is going and why?
- Ministry Effectiveness , Are the church’s ministries producing genuine discipleship and community impact?
- Spiritual Formation , Are people growing in their faith? Is there a culture of discipleship?
- Worship , Is the worship life of the church genuine, participatory, and connected to Scripture?
- Congregational Culture , Is the culture of the congregation healthy? Is there trust, honesty, and genuine community?
- Leadership , Is the leadership team healthy, aligned, and equipped?
- Church Relationships , Are relationships within the congregation healthy? Is conflict handled well?
- Finance and Facilities , Are the church’s finances managed well? Is the facility serving the mission?
- Family Life Stages , Is the church serving people at every stage of life?
How to Use the Full Church Health Audit
The free quick check asks one question in each area and needs no scoring. The separate paid audit uses five scored statements per area. These steps describe the paid audit.
Step 1: Gather the right people
The audit is most valuable when completed by a small group of 3-5 leaders: the pastor, the board chair, and 2-3 key ministry leaders. Each person rates independently before the group discusses. The gaps between individual scores are often the most important conversations.
Step 2: Rate honestly
Each area includes five statements rated on a 1-to-5 scale. The goal is not to produce a high score. The goal is an honest picture of where the church actually is. A score of 2 that is honestly assessed is more valuable than a score of 4 that is inflated by wishful thinking.
Step 3: Identify your two lowest dimensions
The audit produces a summary scorecard. Compare the nine area averages, look for supporting evidence, and identify two priority areas. These are your priority areas for the next 12 months.
Step 4: Write a specific action plan
For each of your two priority dimensions, write a specific 90-day action plan with a named owner and a target date. Vague intentions do not produce change. Specific plans with named owners do.
Step 5: Schedule the next audit
Put the next audit on the calendar before you leave the room. Annual audits allow you to track progress, celebrate improvement, and identify new areas of concern before they become crises.
What the Audit Is Not
- It is not a comparison to other churches
- It is not a performance review of the pastor
- It is not a tool for assigning blame
- It is not a substitute for prayer and discernment
The audit is a tool for honest conversation. The most important thing that happens in a church health audit is not the scores. It is the conversation that the scores generate.
The pastor who approaches the church health audit with genuine curiosity , “I want to know where we actually are” , will get more value from it than the pastor who approaches it with anxiety about what the scores might reveal. The audit is not a verdict. It is a starting point.
Choose the depth your team needs
Start free: The two-page Church Health Quick Check gives you nine discussion questions and a next-step worksheet.
Go deeper: The separate Church Health Audit Tool ($14.99) is a 15-page printable with 45 statements, a 225-point scorecard, two action plans, and a 12-month tracker.
Need the complete version?
Ready to go deeper? Church Annual Planning Kit — $9.99
Looking for a simple way to share the gospel?
The Rescue Gospel framework — Created, Broken, Rescued, Respond — is a free tool any Christian can learn in 10 minutes. Or get the complete church starter bundle for $24.99.